THE ROLE OF THE HUMANITIES AND CULTURE IN THE ACADEMY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.28925/2518-766X.2020.5.13Keywords:
humanities; humanities studies; academy; value.Abstract
Since the days of ancient Greece until 19th century Europe, the humanities have enjoyed respectable and prestigious status. From the second half of the 1990s the status of the humanities and their prestige have changed, primarily due to the depreciation of humanities studies in a purposeful generation, and the scanty representation of graduates of the humanities in the centers of power and employment.
This, in addition to a change in the values of universities — from excellence in research to professional excellence, value changes that have taken place in societies and cultures around the world, as they have in Israel. Humanities careers are not perceived as financially profitable and do not ensure future employment, even for those who wish to focus on an academic career at institutions of higher education or in schools, because there is no demand. Emphasis is placed on the study of mathematics, English, technology, and these are perceived as more “valuable”. With regard to the public-social status, these professions no longer offer prestige or esteem on the part of society. The reduction in demand for the humanities is evident from the number of students, and here the question is whether we should continue to teach and expand the study of the humanities, with all the budgetary implications of operating these programs, in an age when it seems that there is no demand. There are those who believe that the continuing provision of the humanities studies at this time, is a waste of academic resources.
In contrast, others claim that although significant resources are invested in faculties of the humanities, the value of their research output is great and therefore there is need to continue funding these fields, and even to allocate additional resources to humanities research and to programs for outstanding students, with the goal of attracting additional students to the humanities. This study looks at the profile
of students of the humanities, both high school students and high school graduates over the age of 18. In total, 136 subjects participated in this study (73 males and 60 females). The results show a positive and significant correlation between attitudes regarding the humanities and motivation to study these subjects in the future. In addition, a positive correlation was found between values of honesty, helping
others, and contribution to the country, and motivation to study the humanities. The findings of this study contribute by daring to challenge the perception concerning the insignificant status of the humanities in our day and age — aimed at eliminating and rendering them irrelevant.
Downloads
References
Amit, Y. (2002). Teaching the Bible in General Eeducation — A study of the curricula. In A. Hofman & I. Schnell (Eds.), Values and Goals in Israeli Scxhool Curricula (pp. 239–264), Even Yehuda: Reches Publication Educational Projects (in Hebrew).
Ayalon, H. & Yogev, A. (1995). The Status of the Humanities in Israeli High Schools. In D. Chen (Ed.), Education Toward the 21st Century (pp. 211–248), Tel Aviv: Ramot (in Hebrew).
Ben-Ayun, C. (2011). Attitudes of 4th-6th Grade Students in General Public Schools Towards Bible Subjects. Journal for Judaism, Zionism, and Eretz Israel, 8, 139–156 (in Hebrew).
Bloom, A. (1987). The Closing of the American Mind. NY: Simon & Schuster (in English).
Branovsky, Y. (October 25, 2014). Trying to Raise the Humanities. Israel Hayom [in Hebrew]. http://www.israelhayom.co.il/article/228173
Cookson, P. W. & Persell, C. H. (1985). Preparing for Power: American Elite Boarding Schools. NY: Basic Books (in English).
Council for Higher Education. (May 1, 2013). The Higher Education System in Israel 2013 (in Hebrew).
Council for Higher Education. (August 7, 2013). The Higher Education System in Israel 2010–2013 (in Hebrew).
Council for Higher Education. (September 29, 2014). The Higher Education System in Israel 2014 (in Hebrew).
Council for Higher Education. (November 5, 2014). The Higher Education System in Israel: Characteristics and Unique Aspects (in Hebrew).
Elior, R. (2011). The Struggle over the Humanities. Kivunim Hadashim, 25, 73–103 (in Hebrew).
Ezuz, M. (2011). The Future of the Humanities. Igeret, 33, 30–34 (in Hebrew).
Festinger, L. A. (1957). Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford: Stanford University Press (in English).
Frank, J. D. & Gabler, J. (2006). Reconstructing the University. Worldwide Shifts in Academia in the 20th Century. Stanford CA: Stanford University Press (in English).
Friedman, I. & Ben-Galim, N. (1988). Final Examinations Systems in Various Countries. Jerusalem: The Henrieta Szold Institute (in Hebrew).
Gershuni, H. (October 22, 2014). It Is not Necessary to Finance the Hhumanities. NRG (in Hebrew). http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART2/635/269.html
Ginsberg, B. (2011). The Fall of the Faculty:The Rise of the All-Administrative University and Why it Matters. New York: Oxford University Press (in English).
Goldman, S. (2014). Harvard and the Hhumanities. First Things, 239, 20–21 (in English).
Gruber, M. (2005). Bible Instruction in Israel: Problems and Solutions. Al Haperek, 20, 240–247 (in Hebrew).
Hirsch, E. D. (1998). Cultural Literacy. NY: Random House [in English].
Kamens, D. H. & Benavot, A. (1992). A Comparative and Historical Analysis of Mathematics and Science Curricula, 1800–1986. In: J. W. Meyer, D. H. Kamens & A. Benavot (Eds.), School Knowledge for The Masses (pp. 101–123), Washington, DC: Falmer Press (in English).
Kleinberg, A. (2006). The Role of the Iintellectual in the Present Times. Kivunim Hadashim, 13, 28–33 (in Hebrew).
Knesset Research and Information Center. (February 22, 2012). Data on Women in Academia, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
Lamm, Z. (1993). The Pedagogical Meaning of the Problem of the Religious Structure. Position paper submitted to the Pedagogical Secretariat of the Ministfy of Education and Culture (in Hebrew).
Lamm, Z. (1999). Between the Educational Ideologies and the Teaching Methods in Israeli Schools from Their Beginning until Establishment of the State. In R. Globman & Y. Iram (Eds.), Development in Teaching: The Israeli Case (pp. 29–31), Tel Aviv: Ramot, Tel Aviv University (in Hebrew).
Lea, D. (2014). The Future of the Humanities in Today’s Financial Markets. Educational Theory, 64 (3), 261–283 (in English).
Ministry of Education and Culture (1992). “Tomorrow 98” — Report of the supreme committee for scientific and technological education. Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
Nietzsche, F. (1999). Essays on Educating on Culture. Jerusalem: Magnes (in Hebrew).
Nussbaum, M. (2010(. Not for Profit: Why Democracy Needs the Humanities. New Jersey: Princeton University Press (in English).
Razinsky, L. (2014). The State of Israel versus the Humanities. Teorya Uvikoret, 42, 237–255 (in Hebrew).
Rinon, Y. (2014). The Crisis in the Humanities. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad (in Hebrew).
Shamir, E. (2012). Collapsing Values in a Disappearing World — Educating for Values in a “changing society”. Kivunim Hadashim, 26, 161–171 (in Hebrew).
Shamir, Z. (2009). The Study of Hebrew Literature is Dying out. Kivunim Hadashim, 19, 73–80 (in Hebrew).
Shamir, Z. (2012). University Politicization is Deepening under the Patronage “academic freedom”. Kivunim Hadashim, 26, 91–106 (in Hebrew).
Shenhar, A. (2007). Crisis in Jewish Studies — and the Academic World is Silent. Kivunim Hadashim, 16, 77–82 (in Hebrew).
Shkedi, A. (2000). The Place of Bible in the General School. In: D. Yaakobi (Ed.), Nation Building (pp. 109–114), Jerusalem: Magnes (in Hebrew).
Triger, Z. (2007). Law and Theatre as Bridges between the Humanities and the Social Sciences — an article in three scenes. Din Udvarim, 3 (1), 63–105 (in Hebrew).
Yogev, A. (1990). The Future High School: Procedures of change and policy shaping. In Y. Danilov (Ed.), Position Papers — Planning the Education Policy 1998/9 (pp. 29–39), Jerusalem: Ministry of Education and Culture, Pedagogical Secretariat (in Hebrew).
Zakovitch, Y. (1995). Distancing Requires Proximity. Nos’im Behinuch, 4, 7–17 (in Hebrew).
